> HCSA vs PDIS side by side, topic by topic: where they overlap, where they differ and which asks more, with incident deadlines, testing, third parties and fines.

# HCSA vs PDIS

Where they overlap, where they differ and which asks more, topic by topic, with their deadlines and fines side by side.

[HCSA](https://grc.plus/regulation/healthcare-services-act-2020/)

[PDIS](https://grc.plus/regulation/pdis-security-incident-detection-providers/)

## At a Glance

They differ on 0 of 1 topics. Each verdict names what it rests on; read the wording before relying on it.

- **HCSA** Asks more on 0 topics Alone on 0 topics More detailed on 0 topics
- **PDIS** Asks more on 0 topics Alone on 0 topics More detailed on 0 topics

| Topic | HCSA | PDIS | Verdict |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Supervision and enforcement |  |  |  |
| Registration with authorities | HCSA: 2 | PDIS: 1 | **Both cover it**read the wording below |

## What This Covers

The obligations below are summarised from the acts listed here, grouped by topic. Where a side shows nothing on a topic, the acts covered have no specific requirement on it; an act not yet included, national guidance or a supervisor's expectations may still say more. Use it to see where the regimes differ, not as a compliance checklist.

Included

- [HCSA](https://grc.plus/regulation/healthcare-services-act-2020/) Healthcare Services Act 2020 4 requirements

Status

Reviewed against the official texts.

Included

- [PDIS](https://grc.plus/regulation/pdis-security-incident-detection-providers/) PDIS, Référentiel d'exigences, version 2.0, 21 December 2017, ANSSI 4 requirements

Status

Reviewed against the official texts.

## Supervision and enforcement

### Registration with authorities

**Both cover it** read the wording below

- Service licence
  A provider must hold a licence for each licensable healthcare service it offers and approval for each mode of service delivery.
  [HCSA, HCSA](https://grc.plus/regulation/healthcare-services-act-2020/#requirements)
- Specified services
  A provider must obtain Ministry of Health approval before offering a specified service, and offering one without approval is an offence.
  [HCSA, HCSA](https://grc.plus/regulation/healthcare-services-act-2020/#requirements)

- Requirements document
  A qualified detection service must respect the PDIS requirements document, version 2.0 of 21 December 2017.
  [PDIS, PDIS](https://grc.plus/regulation/pdis-security-incident-detection-providers/#requirements)

Requirements are summarised in plain words; the official text prevails. Verdicts compare what the acts covered state, not how a supervisor applies them. Most topics are cross-referenced to NIST CSF 2.0 and ISO/IEC 27001:2022.

## More Comparisons

- [Compare HCSA](https://grc.plus/compare/hcsa/)
- [Compare PDIS](https://grc.plus/compare/pdis/)

Source: https://grc.plus/compare/hcsa-vs-pdis/
