> PHIPA vs POPA side by side, topic by topic: where they overlap, where they differ and which asks more, with incident deadlines, testing, third parties and fines.

# PHIPA vs POPA

Where they overlap, where they differ and which asks more, topic by topic, with their deadlines and fines side by side.

[PHIPA](https://grc.plus/regulation/personal-health-information-protection-act-2004/)

[POPA](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/)

## At a Glance

They differ on 5 of 5 topics. Each verdict names what it rests on; read the wording before relying on it.

- **PHIPA** Asks more on 0 topics Alone on 0 topics More detailed on 0 topics
- **POPA** Asks more on 0 topics Alone on 5 topics More detailed on 0 topics

| Topic | PHIPA | POPA | Verdict |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Governance |  |  |  |
| Management accountability | PHIPA: – | POPA: 1 | **Only POPA**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |
| Protection |  |  |  |
| Data security | PHIPA: – | POPA: 1 | **Only POPA**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |
| Detection and response |  |  |  |
| Reporting to authorities | PHIPA: – | POPA: 1 | **Only POPA**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |
| Privacy and data protection |  |  |  |
| Lawful processing | PHIPA: – | POPA: 2 | **Only POPA**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |
| Impact assessment | PHIPA: – | POPA: 1 | **Only POPA**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |

## What This Covers

The obligations below are summarised from the acts listed here, grouped by topic. Where a side shows nothing on a topic, the acts covered have no specific requirement on it; an act not yet included, national guidance or a supervisor's expectations may still say more. Use it to see where the regimes differ, not as a compliance checklist.

Included

- [PHIPA](https://grc.plus/regulation/personal-health-information-protection-act-2004/) Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004, S.O. 2004, c. 3, Sched. A, with O. Reg. 329/04 5 requirements

Status

Reviewed against the official texts.

Included

- [POPA](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/) Protection of Privacy Act, SA 2024, c P-28.5 6 requirements

Status

Reviewed against the official texts.

## Governance

### Management accountability

**Only POPA** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

NIST CSF 2.0 GV.RR, GV.OV · ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Clause 5.1, A.5.4

Nothing in the acts covered.

- Privacy management program
  Establish and implement a documented privacy management program proportional to the volume and sensitivity of the personal information held, meeting the Ministerial Regulation (section 6: a privacy officer, policies and procedures, a security classification system, mandatory training and periodic review); give anyone who asks a copy within 30 business days.
  [POPA, Section 25](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

## Protection

### Data security

**Only POPA** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

NIST CSF 2.0 PR.DS · ISO/IEC 27001:2022 A.5.12, A.8.10 to A.8.12

Nothing in the acts covered.

- Security arrangements
  Protect personal information with reasonable security arrangements against unauthorized access, collection, use, disclosure or destruction.
  [POPA, Section 10(1)](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

## Detection and response

### Reporting to authorities

**Only POPA** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

NIST CSF 2.0 RS.CO · ISO/IEC 27001:2022 A.5.5

Nothing in the acts covered.

- Breach notification
  Notify the individual, the Commissioner and the Minister without unreasonable delay when an incident creates a real risk of significant harm; the notices are written and contain the information set by the Protection of Privacy (Ministerial) Regulation (section 4).
  [POPA, Section 10(2)](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

## Privacy and data protection

### Lawful processing

**Only POPA** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

NIST Privacy Framework CT.PO-P

Nothing in the acts covered.

- Accuracy for decisions
  Make every reasonable effort to keep personal information used for decisions, including automated ones, accurate and complete, and keep it for at least one year after using it, or a shorter period agreed in writing by the individual, the public body and any body that approves its retention schedule.
  [POPA, Section 6](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)
- No sale of personal information
  Never sell personal information.
  [POPA, Section 11](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

### Impact assessment

**Only POPA** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

NIST Privacy Framework ID.RA-P

Nothing in the acts covered.

- Privacy impact assessment
  Prepare a privacy impact assessment for a new or substantially changed practice, program, project or service involving personal information where a loss could cause significant harm or a submission factor applies, and submit it to the Commissioner where the information is highly sensitive, a significant share of the population is involved, data is matched between public bodies, the program is common or integrated, it uses innovative technology or the Commissioner asks (Ministerial Regulation, section 7).
  [POPA, Section 26](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

Requirements are summarised in plain words; the official text prevails. Verdicts compare what the acts covered state, not how a supervisor applies them. Most topics are cross-referenced to NIST CSF 2.0 and ISO/IEC 27001:2022.

## More Comparisons

- [Compare PHIPA](https://grc.plus/compare/phipa/)
- [Compare POPA](https://grc.plus/compare/popa/)

Source: https://grc.plus/compare/phipa-vs-popa/
