> POPA vs PSD2 Germany side by side, topic by topic: where they overlap, where they differ and which asks more, with incident deadlines, testing, third parties and fines.

# POPA vs PSD2 Germany

Where they overlap, where they differ and which asks more, topic by topic, with their deadlines and fines side by side.

[POPA](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/)

[PSD2 Germany](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/germany/)Payment service providers; authorisation requirements for payment institutions

## At a Glance

They differ on 6 of 7 topics. Each verdict names what it rests on; read the wording before relying on it.

- **POPA** Asks more on 0 topics Alone on 3 topics More detailed on 0 topics
- **PSD2 Germany** Asks more on 0 topics Alone on 2 topics More detailed on 1 topic

| Topic | POPA | PSD2 Germany | Verdict |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Governance |  |  |  |
| Management accountability | POPA: 1 | PSD2 Germany: – | **Only POPA**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |
| Protection |  |  |  |
| Data security | POPA: 1 | PSD2 Germany: 1 | **Both cover it**read the wording below |
| Detection and response |  |  |  |
| Reporting to authorities | POPA: 1 | PSD2 Germany: 3 | **PSD2 Germany more detailed**more requirements on this, not necessarily stricter |
| Privacy and data protection |  |  |  |
| Lawful processing | POPA: 2 | PSD2 Germany: – | **Only POPA**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |
| Impact assessment | POPA: 1 | PSD2 Germany: – | **Only POPA**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |
| Supervision and enforcement |  |  |  |
| Registration with authorities | POPA: – | PSD2 Germany: 7 | **Only PSD2 Germany**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |
| Penalties and liability | POPA: – | PSD2 Germany: 1 | **Only PSD2 Germany**no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered |

## What This Covers

The obligations below are summarised from the acts listed here, grouped by topic. Where a side shows nothing on a topic, the acts covered have no specific requirement on it; an act not yet included, national guidance or a supervisor's expectations may still say more. Use it to see where the regimes differ, not as a compliance checklist.

Included

- [POPA](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/) Protection of Privacy Act, SA 2024, c P-28.5 6 requirements

Status

Reviewed against the official texts.

Included

- [PSD2](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/) Directive (EU) 2015/2366, OJ L 337, 23.12.2015, p. 35 Articles 5, 11, 12, 14, 15, 19, 28, 32, 33, 36, 65 to 68, 70, 95 to 98, 103 · 22 requirements
- [PSD2 SCA RTS](https://grc.plus/regulation/psd2-rts-strong-customer-authentication-2018-389/) Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2018/389, OJ L 69, 13.3.2018, p. 23 Articles 1, 3 to 6, 9 to 12, 15 to 19, 21, 22, 27, 28, 30 to 36 · Annex · 20 requirements Applies to: Payment service providers
- [EBA/GL/2018/05](https://grc.plus/regulation/psd2-guidelines-fraud-reporting/) EBA/GL/2018/05 of 18 July 2018, Guidelines on fraud reporting under the Payment Services Directive 2 (PSD2), as amended by EBA/GL/2020/01 of 22 January 2020 6 requirements
- [EBA ICT Guidelines](https://grc.plus/regulation/eba-guidelines-ict-and-security-risk-management/) EBA/GL/2019/04 (November 2019), as amended by EBA/GL/2025/02 of 11 February 2025; consolidated version of 19 May 2026 5 requirements

National requirements

- [ZAG](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/germany/)
- § 64(4) ZAG

2 national requirements recorded, as departures from the Directive or additions to it. Everything else applies as the Directive has it.

Status

Reviewed against the official texts.

## Key Numbers

### Threshold

POPA: Not in the acts covered

PSD2 Germany: Not used

### Incident reports go to

POPA: Not in the acts covered

PSD2 Germany: Competent authority (providers outside DORA only)

### First notice of an incident

POPA: Not in the acts covered

PSD2 Germany: Without undue delay (providers outside DORA only)

### External assessment or certification

POPA: Not in the acts covered

PSD2 Germany: Independent audit of the security measures; yearly where the transaction risk analysis exemption is used (Payment service providers)

### Review of the risk framework

POPA: Not in the acts covered

PSD2 Germany: Risk assessment to the authority at least once a year

### Registration with the authority

POPA: Not in the acts covered

PSD2 Germany: Authorisation by the home authority before providing payment services

### Maximum fines

POPA: Not in the acts covered

PSD2 Germany: Up to EUR 1 million

## Governance

### Management accountability

**Only POPA** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

NIST CSF 2.0 GV.RR, GV.OV · ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Clause 5.1, A.5.4

- Privacy management program
  Establish and implement a documented privacy management program proportional to the volume and sensitivity of the personal information held, meeting the Ministerial Regulation (section 6: a privacy officer, policies and procedures, a security classification system, mandatory training and periodic review); give anyone who asks a copy within 30 business days.
  [POPA, Section 25](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

Nothing in the acts covered.

## Protection

### Data security

**Both cover it** read the wording below

NIST CSF 2.0 PR.DS · ISO/IEC 27001:2022 A.5.12, A.8.10 to A.8.12

- Security arrangements
  Protect personal information with reasonable security arrangements against unauthorized access, collection, use, disclosure or destruction.
  [POPA, Section 10(1)](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

- Data exchange
  Applies to: Payment service providers
  Without the user actively requesting it, account information providers access the data no more than four times in 24 hours, unless agreed otherwise.
  [PSD2 SCA RTS, Article 36](https://grc.plus/regulation/psd2-rts-strong-customer-authentication-2018-389/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive

## Detection and response

### Reporting to authorities

**PSD2 Germany more detailed** more requirements on this, not necessarily stricter

NIST CSF 2.0 RS.CO · ISO/IEC 27001:2022 A.5.5

- Breach notification
  Notify the individual, the Commissioner and the Minister without unreasonable delay when an incident creates a real risk of significant harm; the notices are written and contain the information set by the Protection of Privacy (Ministerial) Regulation (section 4).
  [POPA, Section 10(2)](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

- Incident reporting and fraud statistics
  Major incidents are reported (under DORA for most providers since 2025) and fraud data is sent at least yearly.
  [PSD2, Article 96](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive
- Major incident reporting
  Report major operational or security incidents to the home authority without undue delay and inform affected users. Since 17 January 2025 it no longer applies to providers in DORA's scope, which report under DORA.
  [PSD2, Article 96(1)-(5)](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive
- Fraud statistics
  Statistical data on fraud by means of payment, at least yearly, to the authority.
  [PSD2, Article 96(6)](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive

## Privacy and data protection

### Lawful processing

**Only POPA** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

NIST Privacy Framework CT.PO-P

- Accuracy for decisions
  Make every reasonable effort to keep personal information used for decisions, including automated ones, accurate and complete, and keep it for at least one year after using it, or a shorter period agreed in writing by the individual, the public body and any body that approves its retention schedule.
  [POPA, Section 6](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)
- No sale of personal information
  Never sell personal information.
  [POPA, Section 11](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

Nothing in the acts covered.

### Impact assessment

**Only POPA** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

NIST Privacy Framework ID.RA-P

- Privacy impact assessment
  Prepare a privacy impact assessment for a new or substantially changed practice, program, project or service involving personal information where a loss could cause significant harm or a submission factor applies, and submit it to the Commissioner where the information is highly sensitive, a significant share of the population is involved, data is matched between public bodies, the program is common or integrated, it uses innovative technology or the Commissioner asks (Ministerial Regulation, section 7).
  [POPA, Section 26](https://grc.plus/regulation/alberta-protection-of-privacy-act/#requirements)

Nothing in the acts covered.

## Supervision and enforcement

### Registration with authorities

**Only PSD2 Germany** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

Nothing in the acts covered.

- Authorisation, capital and safeguarding
  A payment institution is authorised by its home authority before it starts, holds initial capital and own funds, and keeps users' funds safe.
  [PSD2, Articles 5-12](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive
- Application for authorisation
  The application covers the programme of operations, a three-year business plan, capital, safeguarding, governance, incident and complaint procedures, sensitive payment data, business continuity, a security policy and risk assessment, AML controls, owners and directors. The authority decides within three months; the authorisation is valid across the EU.
  [PSD2, Articles 5, 11, 12](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive
- Registers, agents, passporting and bank account access
  Authorised and registered providers are listed in public registers; agents and outsourcing are notified; a passport opens the EU; banks give payment institutions fair access to accounts.
  [PSD2, Articles 14-15, 19, 28, 36](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive
- Public registers
  Each member state keeps a public register of payment institutions, their agents and branches, exempt institutions and account information providers; the EBA keeps a central register.
  [PSD2, Articles 14-15](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive
- Small payment institutions and account information providers
  Member states may register small payment institutions instead of authorising them; account information providers are registered.
  [PSD2, Articles 32-33](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive
- Small payment institutions in Germany Differs Optional
  No: the national law has no small payment institution regime.
  [PSD2 Germany,](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/germany/#requirements)
- Account information providers
  Registered instead of authorised, with professional indemnity insurance; most of Titles III and IV does not apply to them.
  [PSD2, Article 33](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/#requirements) · applies as in the Directive

### Penalties and liability

**Only PSD2 Germany** no specific requirement on the other side in the acts covered

Nothing in the acts covered.

- Penalties in Germany Differs
  Administrative offences carry fines up to EUR 1,000,000 (breach of enforceable orders, § 64(1)), EUR 300,000 (§ 64(3) nos. 1-2) and EUR 100,000 (other § 64(3) offences); no turnover-based cap; unauthorised business is a criminal offence (§ 63). (§ 64(4) ZAG)
  [PSD2 Germany, § 64(4) ZAG](https://grc.plus/regulation/revised-payment-services-directive-psd2/germany/#requirements)

Requirements are summarised in plain words; the official text prevails. Verdicts compare what the acts covered state, not how a supervisor applies them. Most topics are cross-referenced to NIST CSF 2.0 and ISO/IEC 27001:2022. 10 topics where all apply the Directive as it is are not shown.

## More Comparisons

- [Compare POPA](https://grc.plus/compare/popa/)
- [Compare PSD2 Germany](https://grc.plus/compare/psd2-germany/)

Source: https://grc.plus/compare/popa-vs-psd2-germany/
